26 Great Canadian Butter Tart Recipes

Updated on May 30, 2018 by Jenny Potter

Known around the world as a uniquely Canadian dessert, butter tarts are one of the tastiest things to come out of the True North. Nothing beats the flaky pastry filled with a perfectly sticky-sweet centre. Whether you prefer them plain, studded with raisins or turned into a cheesecake, we've got 26 recipes to satisfy your sweet tooth.

  • Jen Scott’s Butter Tarts
     
    1 of 26

    Jen Scott’s Butter Tarts

    <p>If you’ve taken the time to tap the trees, boil the sap and bottle your maple syrup, this delicious recipe alone is worth all your effort.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/recipe/jen-scotts-butter-tarts/16518/" target="_blank"><strong>Jen Scott’s Butter Tarts</strong></a></p>
  • Pecan Butter Tart Squares
     
    2 of 26

    Pecan Butter Tart Squares

    <p>Forget the finicky pastry and bake up a batch of these simple butter tart squares that have all the ooey-gooey goodness of your favourite tart. Sweet, buttery shortbread is the base for these delectable Canadian treats.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/pecan-butter-tart-squares/19392/" target="_blank">Pecan Butter Tart Squares</a></strong></p>
  • Anna Olson's Pecan Butter Tarts
     
    3 of 26

    Anna Olson's Pecan Butter Tarts

    <p>Our favourite star baker, Anna Olson, knows butter tarts inside and out. Her various butter tart recipes span years and categories, all satisfying our proud Canadian sweet tooth. Here, Olson creates a pecan pie-inspired version, acting as a tribute to Canada’s friendliness with our pie-loving neighbours to the south.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/pecan-butter-tarts/12426/" target="_blank">Anna Olson's Pecan Butter Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Butter Tart Pinwheels
     
    4 of 26

    Butter Tart Pinwheels

    <p>Butter tarts turn into sticky, decadent curlicues that skip the muss and fuss of the traditional recipe. These pinwheels stack up just like a holiday cookie, adding an unexpected, classic Canadian pop to festive sweets trays. You can make these with either puff pastry or traditional pie dough — just be sure to make them!</p> <p>Get the recipes for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/recipe/butter-tart-pinwheels/18683/" target="_blank"><strong>Butter Tart Pinwheels</strong></a></p>
  • Chocolate Bottom Butter Tarts
     
    5 of 26

    Chocolate Bottom Butter Tarts

    <p>Shake up the classic tarts by baking a crumbly, chocolatey base. There’s still your favourite sweet, gooey filling, topped with a chocolate drizzle.</p> <p>Get the recipes for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/recipe/chocolate-bottom-butter-tarts/18829/" target="_blank"><strong>Chocolate Bottom Butter Tarts</strong></a></p>
  • The Best Butter Tart Cheesecake
     
    6 of 26

    The Best Butter Tart Cheesecake

    <p>Whether you're pro-raisins or purely a pecan fan, a party isn’t really a party without butter tarts. Impress the butter tart lovers in your life with an incredibly indulgent cheesecake, topped with a sticky, caramel butter tart filling and salty, crunchy pecans. Sub the nuts for raisins if that’s your jam.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/blog/the-best-butter-tart-cheesecake/" target="_blank"><strong>The Best Butter Tart Cheesecake</strong></a></p>
  • Butter Tart Cinnamon Buns
     
    7 of 26

    Butter Tart Cinnamon Buns

    <p>All the gooey goodness you know and love about butter tarts, baked into a warm, doughy cinnamon bun. Yep. You’re Welcome.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/blog/you-havent-lived-until-youve-tasted-butter-tart-cinnamon-buns/" target="_blank">Butter Tart Cinnamon Buns</a></strong></p>
  • Pumpkin Pie Butter Tarts
     
    8 of 26

    Pumpkin Pie Butter Tarts

    <p>These pumpkin pie butter tarts combine the best tastes of the holidays in one delicious morsel.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/pumpkin-pie-butter-tarts/12911/" target="_blank">Michael Smith's Pumpkin Pie Butter Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Maple Butter Tarts with Candied Pecans and Cranberry Purée
     
    9 of 26

    Maple Butter Tarts with Candied Pecans and Cranberry Purée

    <p>This dessert consists of classic maple butter tarts but with a unique twist: they're served with some crunchy candied pecans and a sweet, tangy cranberry sauce for a little extra bite.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/maple-butter-tarts-with-candied-pecans-and-cranberry-puree/15186/" target="_blank"><strong>Maple Butter Tarts with Candied Pecans and Cranberry Purée</strong></a></p>
  • Brown Butter Tarts with Maple and Nutmeg
     
    10 of 26

    Brown Butter Tarts with Maple and Nutmeg

    <p>Warm, sticky, brown butter tarts are the perfect treat to satisfy your sweet cravings.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/brown-butter-tarts-with-maple-and-nutmeg/12909/" target="_blank"><strong>Michael Smith's Brown Butter Tarts with Maple and Nutmeg</strong></a></p>
  • Bacon Butter Tarts
     
    11 of 26

    Bacon Butter Tarts

    <p>Sweet and salty is a match made in food heaven, especially when it involves salty bacon in sweet, creamy butter tarts.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/bacon-butter-tarts/18018/" target="_blank"><strong>Bacon Butter Tarts</strong></a></p>
  • Burnt Toffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Tart
     
    12 of 26

    Burnt Toffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Tart

    <p>An elegant and surprisingly easy-to-make treat filled with burnt chocolate toffee and smoother peanut butter, and topped with a coffee caramel sauce. </p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/green-and-blacks-organic-burnt-toffee-chocolate-peanut-butter-tart/14011/"><strong>Burnt Toffee Chocolate Peanut Butter Tart</strong></a></p>
  • Butter Tart Coffee Cake
     
    13 of 26

    Butter Tart Coffee Cake

    <p>A moist cake bottom sitting beneath a perfectly gooey butter tart topping, this dessert-style coffee cake is just the ticket.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/butter-tart-coffee-cake/12780/" target="_blank"><strong>Anna Olson's Butter Tart Coffee Cake</strong></a></p>
  • Apple Pie Butter Tarts
     
    14 of 26

    Apple Pie Butter Tarts

    <p>A mashup of two tasty Canadian favourites, even raisin haters will love the tasty morsels of apple in each gooey bite. Plus these sweet tarts are flavoured with warm spices like cinnamon and nutmeg making them extra irresistible.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/apple-pie-butter-tarts/19936/" target="_blank">Apple Pie Butter Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Baklava Butter Tart Bake
     
    15 of 26

    Baklava Butter Tart Bake

    <p>A tasty dessert or brunch casserole that brings together your two favourite desserts in one gooey, flaky pan, filled with crunchy walnuts and plump raisins.</p> <p>Get the recipes for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/recipe/baklava-butter-tart-bake/18811/" target="_blank"><strong>Baklava Butter Tart Bake</strong></a></p>
  • Butterless Butter Tarts
     
    16 of 26

    Butterless Butter Tarts

    <p>Leave it to Anna Olson to master a vegan butter tart that tastes like the real deal. Silken tofu is a good substitute for eggs, while vegetable oil and soy milk replace the butter in the flaky pastry.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/butterless-butter-tarts/12157/" target="_blank">Anna Olson’s Butterless Butter Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Butter Tart Ice Cream
     
    17 of 26

    Butter Tart Ice Cream

    <p>Sweet, buttery pecan swirls and pieces of butter tarts make this a splendid treat that tastes just like your favourite tart.</p> <p>Get the recipes for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/recipe/butter-tart-ice-cream/18643/" target="_blank"><strong>Butter Tart Ice Cream</strong></a></p>
  • Waterloo County Butter Tarts
     
    18 of 26

    Waterloo County Butter Tarts

    <p>These classic tarts are so good, people have been known to sneak them off the dessert table before dinner, just to make sure they get one! Lard ensures that the pastry is perfectly flaky.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/waterloo-county-butter-tarts-/16332/" target="_blank">Waterloo County Butter Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Caramel Butter Tarts
     
    19 of 26

    Caramel Butter Tarts

    <p>These deliciously decadent caramel butter tarts have a thin, flaky crust and a gooey, buttery caramelized filling.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/caramel-butter-tarts/3834/" target="_blank"><strong>Anna Olson's Caramel Butter Tarts</strong></a></p>
  • Maple Butter Tarts with Currants
     
    20 of 26

    Maple Butter Tarts with Currants

    <p>Instead of sultanas, opt for another fruity filling with currants. Used in traditional Canadian baking, these dark raisins are made from dried zante grapes and pack a lot of flavour in each tiny bite.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/maple-butter-tarts-with-currants/7178/" target="_blank">Maple Butter Tarts with Currants</a></strong></p>
  • No Money Butter Tarts
     
    21 of 26

    No Money Butter Tarts

    <p>A sprinkling of coconut in the shells of these tasty tarts gives them a delightfully chewy texture with each bite.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/no-honey-butter-tarts/11559/" target="_blank">No Money Butter Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Nanaimo Bar Butter Tarts
     
    22 of 26

    Nanaimo Bar Butter Tarts

    <p>East and West come together for the ultimate Canadian dessert. Coconut, walnut and custard drizzled with melted chocolate make for a delicious and unique treat.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/nanaimo-butter-tarts/21806/" target="_blank">Nanaimo Bar Butter Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Butter Tart Pop Tarts
     
    23 of 26

    Butter Tart Pop Tarts

    <p>DIY your childhood favourites for a nostalgic treat you can’t get anywhere else. Instead of formed into classic crimped tarts, pastry is formed into hand-held pockets, and filled with the classic gooey filling. Feel free to freeze for a fun and tasty treat.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/butter-tart-pop-tarts/20558/" target="_blank">Butter Tart Pop Tarts</a></strong></p>
  • Anna Olson’s Butter Tart Bars
     
    24 of 26

    Anna Olson’s Butter Tart Bars

    <p>A simple cookie base holds a delicious, maple filling studded with chocolate chips and walnuts. Slice into bars or squares for Canada Day, or as a part of a spread at your next backyard barbecue.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/butter-tart-bars/21751/" target="_blank">Anna Olson’s Butter Tart Bars</a></strong></p>
  • Canadian Maple Butter Tart Cheesecake
     
    25 of 26

    Canadian Maple Butter Tart Cheesecake

    <p>Take your cheesecake to the next level by topping it with a sticky-sweet maple butter tart filling with loads of pecans.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/recipe/canadian-maple-butter-tart-cheesecake/21805/" target="_blank">Canadian Maple Butter Tart Cheesecake</a></strong></p>
  • Pecan Whisky Butter Tart
     
    26 of 26

    Pecan Whisky Butter Tart

    <p>The classic tart gets a grown-up twist with the addition of Canadian rye whisky. These pretty crimped pastries are still filled with sticky, dripping filling, albeit, perfectly spiked and studded with pecans.</p> <p>Get the recipe for <strong><a href="http://www.foodnetwork.ca/shows/great-canadian-cookbook/blog/pecan-whisky-butter-tarts-are-a-classic-canadian-treat-all-grown-up/" target="_blank">Pecan Whisky Butter Tart</a></strong></p>
  • Start Over
    Next Gallery

    26 Sweet Maple Recipes to Celebrate Syrup Season

    More Galleries

Comments

You Might Also Like

Food Network Member